MacMusic.org  |  PcMusic.org  |  440Software  |  440Forums.com  |  440Tv  |  Zicos.com  |  AudioLexic.org
Loading... visiteurs connectés
Bienvenue invité
> Removing Clicks, removing clicks from records
tromba
posté mer. 17 déc. 2003, 04:08
Message #1


Newbie


Groupe : Members
Messages : 11
Inscrit : 31 juil. 03
Lieu : Montgomery - US
Membre no 22,226




I've just recently purchased a 12" powerbook and can't find the tools to do what I want. I've used Cool Edit in Windows to record the record and then to remove the clicks. This has done a pretty good job. I have Audacity to record and have the files on the computer. I can't find anything to remove the clicks.

Any suggestions?
Go to the top of the page
 
+Quote Post
 
Start new topic
Réponse(s)
WaterDog
posté mer. 31 déc. 2003, 16:28
Message #2


Newbie


Groupe : Members
Messages : 6
Inscrit : 19 déc. 03
Lieu : Portland - US
Membre no 31,476




Sadly, as I am archiving records every day, I don't really have time to use the pencil tool--although I agree it is really the best way to take out the pop and leave the rest of the audio untouched.

For software solutions, it still looks like SoundSoap Pro or RayGun Pro will be the best pro-sumer options out there. SoundSoap Pro isn't out yet, but I am downloading a demo of RayGun Pro to check out.

There is also TC Electronic's "Restoration" suite, which seems like an amazing tool--and does include pop removal in it's arsenal--but it is an $800 (soon to be $1,500) software add-on to their $1,000-$1,500 hardware audio system. Not in the budget for this year, or next.

FWIW, Peak's "Repair Clicks..." feature is designed to be tuneable to recognize the spike of a digital pop and remove it. It would ideally ignore a kick drum, clave or other sharp transient. For example, the manual says a sample value of -100 followed by a value of 10,000 is probably a click, and not part of the music. It also gives starting points for cleaning up audio. But Bias also admit that "Repair Clicks..." isn't ideal for cleaning up vinyl. Sigh.

Someone already said this, but as much as I like RayGun for some noise removal, it mostly converts clicks to "thumps,' and I get aliasing and artifacts with a lot of settings anyway. Maybe the Pro version is better, I'm a few years behind upgrading.

I also have tons of vinyl I want to archive, so am glad for the discussion.

The search continues!


--------------------
H. Perkins
WaterDog Studio
Go to the top of the page
 
+Quote Post

Les messages de ce sujet
- tromba   Removing Clicks   mer. 17 déc. 2003, 04:08
- - editbrain   you should check into bias peak. it is very profe...   mer. 17 déc. 2003, 23:30
- - Synthetic   remove clicks? not sure what exactly this means......   jeu. 18 déc. 2003, 15:30
- - tromba   Removing clicks and pops from records. I'm con...   ven. 19 déc. 2003, 04:50
- - Synthetic   oh... I see maybe Peak LE? I think it was about ...   ven. 19 déc. 2003, 05:29
- - editbrain   i am not sure if peak LE has that capabilities. i...   ven. 19 déc. 2003, 08:56
- - rickenbacker   Mmm, Peak 4. It really is very nice. But I thi...   ven. 19 déc. 2003, 13:02
- - tromba   QUOTE (editbrain @ Dec 17 2003, 22:30)you sho...   lun. 29 déc. 2003, 21:00
- - drewmtb   I use amadeus. I use to use cooledit many years a...   lun. 29 déc. 2003, 22:45
- - editbrain   i have had problems with peak finding pops also. ...   mar. 30 déc. 2003, 08:51
- - WaterDog   Peak by iteself may not be enough to clean up reco...   mar. 30 déc. 2003, 16:07
- - editbrain   waterdog, i agree it is very time consuming to use...   mar. 30 déc. 2003, 18:19
- - Synthetic   I just wonder how software is supposed to automati...   mar. 30 déc. 2003, 19:25
- - editbrain   Synthetic, I agree. that is why i was describing...   mer. 31 déc. 2003, 06:56
- - WaterDog   ...not to belabor the point, but check this.... h...   mer. 31 déc. 2003, 16:40
- - tromba   I've just done about 20 records and went back ...   ven. 2 janv. 2004, 05:51
- - tromba   QUOTE (Synthetic @ Dec 30 2003, 18:25)I just ...   ven. 2 janv. 2004, 05:57


Reply to this topicStart new topic
1 utilisateur(s) sur ce sujet (1 invité(s) et 0 utilisateur(s) anonyme(s))
0 membre(s) :

 

Version bas débit - jeudi 27 févr. 2025, 04:49
- © MacMusic 1997-2008