Pro Tools, ..motu, ..or Logic?, What to buy and what all do I need? Options

[Nels]

Well, I've read and then read some more, but I'm still a bit in the dark. Currently I own a modeling synth(Technics WAS1), digital multitracker(Fostex DMT 8vL), DBX 160SL Stereo Compressor, effects proccesors, etc. I want to get into the world of computer sequencing, recording, editing, mixing and hopefully mastering and I'll be laying down guitar & Bass tracks as well, but I'm wary as to what to get in the way of software/hardware.. Now, I'm aware that Pro Tools is the most widely used for it's ease of use, but it doesn't offer a suround application right out of the box as I've read, Logic does. And if I'm not mistaken, Motu also offers a surround apllication. So the question that I have is, ..Pro Tools 002, Logic 6.2.2, or Motu 828mkll & DP4 Machfive? And I'm not certain exactly all that I'll need, specifically. The only thing I've been confident in buying so far was the new Mac G4 Laptop w/ Superdrive. ...If anyone can help me with specifics on any or all of the platforms mentioned, as to what all I'll need to get to have a complete system set up and running, Id so appreciate it. For example, when Digidesign 002 says to just plug in the firewire cable, install the software and your ready to record, is that really all there is to it? Asside from having a monitor source(speakers), good mics, etc,. of course. Also, can I and if so, should I make use of my beautiful DBX 160SL, which I paid big big bucks for or should I sell it along with my outboard digital multitracker? ....Any specific help would be greatly appreciated. Thanks, Miles

[garyyamane]

DP4 includes MIDI sequencing and surround sound processing, Audio Desk only audio recording. It is very processor intensive and if you are planning on using a Powerbook you need to know that the number of tracks that you record (with plug-in effects) will be limited to 7 or 8 depending on how many plug ins you use. With none, you will be able to record at least 16 tracks of simultaneous audio. The MOTU 828mkII (firewire interface) works quite well but only has 2 inputs with preamps so if you are going to need more mics, you will need another mic preamp. I am using the PreSonus Digimax Lt which has 8 mic preamps and light pipe out (which synchs nicely with the 828mkII). Another factor will be hard drive speed. The standard Powerbook hard drive will be ok but better to get an external 7200 firewire drive or upgrade the internal drive to a 7200. Also max out the RAM.